Back to 158 FIRST AVE NYC LLC

All 4 tenant reviews.

158 FIRST AVE NYC LLC · avg 1.5 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Jan 2026

Pros: Location is great Cons: Landlord was sued and new property management are not responsive at all

158 1 AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★★Apr 2025

Pros: good location, helplful super, friendly neighbors Cons: problems often left unfixed for a long time, frequent issues with heat and other issues in the building, landlord can be rude, can be noisy, halls and stairs not very well maintained, there is an ongoing issue with illegal short term rentals in the building

158 1 AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★Sep 2021

Pros: Location was close to great restaurants Cons: Roaches and mice! Awful landlord!

158 1 AVENUE · Manhattan
★★★★Nov 2020

Pros: The Mexican restaurant next to it is good Cons: I rented through apartment 212. If you are considering tending through them I strongly discourage that. They have an F on the BBB and they definitely earned that. The building itself has rats on the 1st floor by the trash. I had mice and roaches in my apartment on the 5th floor. The power cut out every day in the summer because the entire apartment was on one circuit. I got locked out and nearly evicted because apartment 212 illegally subdivided the apartment. The apartment was a fire hazard because my room was the only room that had access to the fire escape. These were just the worst parts of the apartment, I can’t even get into all of the small annoyances. 0/10 Advice to landlord: Just gut renovate the entire building

158 1 AVENUE · Manhattan
Advertisement