Back to 136 WEST 17TH STREET

All 7 tenant reviews.

136 WEST 17TH STREET · avg 4.4 ★★★★ · New York City

★★★★Feb 2026

Pros: No real issues to speak of. Clean, quiet-ish. Live -in super very nice and responsive. Cons: There were a few instances of homeless people making their way into the building.

131 WEST 16 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★May 2025

Pros: The building is truly a community. Very clean, great location. I loved living here. Cons: Such a minor con, but you could not get down to the basement to take out trash or do laundry after a certain time.

131 WEST 16 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Sep 2023

Pros: This has been a wonderful building to live in. Very quiet in the rear facing apartments and the building is always clean, the basement is impeccable and the super is extremely helpful and responsive Cons: Very hot in the winter

131 WEST 16 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★May 2022

Pros: The best super I have ever seen. Each apartment is individually owned. Responsive building. Friendly quiet neighbors. Cons: My specific apartment did not have a lot of natural light.

131 WEST 16 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Apr 2022

Pros: Excellent location. Tree lined street. Great mix of people. Cons: This is a pre-war building and as such it comes with the issue such a building will have. Maintenance of the exterior of the structure has the potential to be an ongoing issue as the building ages. Advice to landlord: Under the new property management company we have the opportunity to improve communication with the tenants which was less then ideal under the old management company.

131 WEST 16 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★May 2021

Pros: Steve the super is very nice and helpful Cons: Owners are terrible and everyone in the building hates renters. Neighbors are very rude and literally bully renters.

131 WEST 16 STREET · Manhattan
★★★★★Jan 2021

Pros: responsive super and working laundry room Cons: none to report Advice to landlord: none to report

131 WEST 16 STREET · Manhattan
Advertisement