Back to 123 ON THE PARK LLC

All 11 tenant reviews.

123 ON THE PARK LLC · avg 4.0 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Mar 2026

“Unit 1H Pros: This building is clean, neighbors are friendly, and layouts are spacious. Concierge staff are especially courteous and helpful. Cons: The property manager is a jerk and threatens to fine you for every little thing (especially with pet ownership). It never happens, but he's really rude about it. Maintenance doesn't seem to know why they're referred to your apartment and can enter at the wrong times, which is the manager's fault 100%.”

— 100 PARKSIDE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Aug 2025

“Pros: The units are fairly large with good closet space. The concierge are the best, especially Mira. And the handyman moves quickly. The building is very family friendly, it felt like everyone had a dog or a baby. Cons: The gym is quite old and in the basement. Some residents let their children use the hallway as a play space but aside from that, it’s very quiet.”

— 45 WOODRUFF AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Aug 2024

“Pros: Building staff. Location close to subway. Great neighbors Cons: Common spaces look tired (old looking carpets/peeling wallpaper, etc.). Management not helpful/responsive to tenant needs Advice to landlord: More proactive engagement with tenants”

— 45 WOODRUFF AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★May 2023

“Pros: Nice location near the park. Roof deck, decent gym. Cons: Used to have 24h concierge, not anymore. Management got rid of it and replaced the night shift with an intercom. The roof on the 123 side used to be pretty nice, but has been destroyed and "under construction" for years now.”

— 100 PARKSIDE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★May 2023

“Pros: Nice building, doorman, good location, good light Cons: Faulty electrical, slow response time, aggressive rent raising in between leases”

— 100 PARKSIDE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Dec 2022

“Pros: Amazing staffs and maintenance crew. The management is very responsive, kind, and helpful. Cons: The amenity spaces are not well maintained. Furnitre and equipment are dirty. Everything else is a top notch! Advice to landlord: I wish the public amenity spaces are better taken cared. Other than that, there's nothing else to complain.”

— 45 WOODRUFF AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Nov 2021

“Pros: The staff is incredible - friendly, charming, patient, and helpful. My apartment is quiet and was very clean when I moved in. Maintenance requests are taken care of extremely fast. And being right across from the park is a dream. Oh and the mail/package system is incredible! I don’t ever have to worry about my packages getting stolen. Cons: The kitchens were built a little strangely - the vent over the stove pushes air into a cupboard over the stove. And the microwave is in a lot cabinet. Overall, it’s not a problem - just a NYC apartment quirk, I think.”

— 45 WOODRUFF AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Sep 2021

“Pros: Front desk & Porter staff Gym Rooftop Proximity to Prospect Park & subway Cons: Moved into this building 5 years ago. A 24 hour front desk team is what attracted us to the building. Since then, it’s been reduced, some days down to 8 hours or none at all. We share a connection to 125 Parkside Ave. When their concierge calls out, they pull the front desk staff to cover their lobby. When asked, I was told “it’s company policy to have someone at 125 at all times” and no word on why 10 St Paul’s is the stepchild. Rent continued to go up regardless. Unit rates are quite sporadic. Much larger units pay less than smaller etc. For the most part tenants move out once their free month concessions expire prior to lease renewal. Nobody has been in this building longer than my 5 year stay. I’ve also been told management prefers tenants move out rather than deal with complaints/concerns. When we moved in fall of 2016, we were also under the impression that the rooftop was to be complete that coming summer. It was finally complete for tenants summer 2020. We’d be paying for that space as well for 3+ years without have access to it at all. Advice to landlord: Concessions for tenants now that amenities have been robbed from us. Transparency around changes & proper prompt responses for all.”

— 100 PARKSIDE AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jul 2021

“Pros: Great location, nice concierge staff, cool rooftop space, good amenities (eg, AC/heat and in-unit washer/dryer), and nice apt layouts. Cons: Maintenance staff doesn’t really fix issues thoroughly. No screens on windows that barely open. Kind of sterile. Dirty/Damaged parts of common areas.”

— 45 WOODRUFF AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jun 2021

“Pros: Concierge staff is nice Apartments are big Well equipped New construction Cons: Maintenance staff doesn’t know how to properly fix appliances Floors are trashed from previous tenants (cheap laminate) Walls are SUPER THIN. You can hear conversations of your neighbors. Super/building manager refused to wear his mask despite me asking several times Floors, walls, elevators all need to be cleaned in common areas Advice to landlord: People want to live somewhere for longer than a year, but you make it so hard and unpleasant most move out. Stop nickel-and-diming people and start caring more about your residents.”

— 45 WOODRUFF AVENUE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Mar 2021

“Pros: Clean bldg, nice amenities. On site staff friendly and helpful. Cons: Management company was unresponsive and not willing to work with tenant in a reasonable manner to resolve issues. Advice to landlord: Respond to tenants in a timely and reasonable manner”

— 100 PARKSIDE AVENUE · Brooklyn
Advertisement