Back to 1223 ATLANTIC LLC

All 3 tenant reviews.

1223 ATLANTIC LLC · avg 2.0 ★★★★★ · New York City

★★★★★Aug 2025

“Pros: Conveniently located near A/C subway line, access to many stores and restaurants. Cons: They definitely control the heat in the winter. Half-a**ed job when it comes to pest control.”

— 54 HERKIMER PLACE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jan 2025

“Pros: I love the neighborhood and the other tenants. Objectively, the units are great Cons: Management sucks, the backyard is unusable, and again management sucks Advice to landlord: Be less abrasively negligent”

— 54 HERKIMER PLACE · Brooklyn
★★★★★Jun 2023

“Pros: When I first rented I got a pretty good deal. There is a large shared backyard, shared laundry, and dishwashers in every unit. The bedroom is large. Cons: The building is not well maintained, the backyard is gross, and the management company will not treat you well. The heat is illegal. I had to push back a lot and involve HPD to get proper heating installed in my unit (1R) but the rest of the units still have inadequate heating as far as I know.”

— 54 HERKIMER PLACE · Brooklyn
Advertisement