424 SUTTER AVENUE is a mid-century 1930 building, 6 units in Brownsville, NYC. Owned by 424 BROOKLYN REALTYCORP. Public records show 14 311 complaints on file. Tenant-impact history includes 1 eviction.
Drop this scorecard into a tenant guide, blog post, or wiki. It updates itself as new violations are filed.
Brooklyn · February 2026
Best & worst months to sign a lease
Potential savings: ~13% by timing your move to March.
Monthly counts over the last 7 years · all data sources
No HPD records on file in the last 7 years.
Portfolio-level grade reflects the landlord's buildings across NYC, weighted by unit count. Individual building grades may differ.
View full landlord profileTop 1 by score · of 3 total
ACRIS deeds and regulatory filings
Eviction Executed — Apt STORE 3 — Possession
Graffiti
Water System — No Water (WNW)
Water System — No Water (WNW)
Water System — No Water (WNW)
Illegal Dumping — Removal Request
Noise - Commercial — Banging/Pounding
Noise - Commercial — Banging/Pounding
Noise - Commercial — Banging/Pounding
Dirty Condition — Trash
Brownsville has long been one of Brooklyn's toughest neighborhoods, but community-led organizations like the Brownsville Community Justice Center are driving change. Public housing dominates the landscape, rents are among the city's lowest, and a fierce sense of community persists.