What is the rent for a studio at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

Based on recent listing data, rent for a studio at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 ranges from $2,465 to $3,335 per month, with a median of $2,900.

What is the rent for a 1-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

Based on recent listing data, rent for a 1-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 ranges from $2,576 to $3,484 per month, with a median of $3,030.

What is the rent for a 2-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

Based on recent listing data, rent for a 2-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 ranges from $2,848 to $3,852 per month, with a median of $3,350.

What is the rent for a 3-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

Based on recent listing data, rent for a 3-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 ranges from $3,553 to $4,807 per month, with a median of $4,180.

What is the rent for a 4-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

Based on recent listing data, rent for a 4-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 ranges from $3,825 to $5,175 per month, with a median of $4,500.

How does rent at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 compare to the neighborhood?

Compared to other buildings in the 11238 zip code: 1-bedroom rents are about 73% above the neighborhood median.

Is 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 rent stabilized?

Based on available records, 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 is not currently registered as rent stabilized. Rents at this building are likely set at market rate.

When is the cheapest time to rent at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

Based on historical listing data, March tends to be the most affordable month to sign a lease at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238, while May is typically the most expensive. Timing your move to March could save approximately 14% compared to peak pricing.

Who is the landlord of 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

The registered owner of 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 is B UNDERHILL LLC. You can view their full portfolio of buildings on Lucid Rents.

Is the landlord of 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 a good landlord?

12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238, owned by B UNDERHILL LLC, has an overall grade of A (4.0/5) on Lucid Rents. The building has 14 recorded violations. Tenants have left 1 review. Check tenant reviews for firsthand experiences.

What is the building rating for 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 has an overall grade of A with a score of 4.0 out of 5 on Lucid Rents. This score is based on violations, complaints, and tenant reviews.

Are there violations or complaints at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

Yes, 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 has 14 housing violations and 43 complaints on record. Visit the building page on Lucid Rents to see the full history, including violation classes and complaint types.

What amenities does 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 have?

12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 offers 1 amenities including Good Cause. View the full amenity list on the building page.

What schools are near 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

There are 10 schools near 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238, including 4 public schools, 3 charter schools, 3 private schools. Nearby schools include Public School 9 The Sarah Smith Garnet School (3 min walk), Public School 9 The Sarah Smith Garnet School (3 min walk), Gotham Professional Arts Academy (4 min walk), P.s. K753 - School For Career Development (5 min walk), Achievement First Endeavor Charter School (3 min walk), and more.

What public transit is near 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 has 4 transit options nearby. The closest include: bus: WASHINGTON AV/PROSPECT PL (B45), 0.27 mi away.

Is 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 safe? What is the crime rate nearby?

The 11238 zip code where 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 is located had 1,430 crime incidents in the past 2 years, including 89 violent crimes, 570 property crimes, and 771 quality-of-life incidents. Check the neighborhood report card for 11238 for full details.

When was 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 built and how many units does it have?

12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 was built in 1930, has 4 floors, contains 8 total units.

What do tenants say about living at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?

12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 has 1 tenant review with an average rating of 4.0 out of 5. 0 out of 1 reviewers would recommend this building.

12 UNDERHILL AVENUE — Rent Intelligence for Prospect Heights, NYC

Prospect Heights · Brooklyn, NY, 11238

Built 19304 floors8 unitsBBL 3011220039

Current rent range

$2,465 – $5,175 / mo

5 bedroom bands tracked · sampled from recent listings

Leave a review

★★★★★4.01 reviews

Verified reviewsBUOwned byB UNDERHILL LLC3 bldgs

12 UNDERHILL AVENUE

Brooklyn, NY, 11238

12 UNDERHILL AVENUE is a mid-century 1930 building, 8 units in Prospect Heights, NYC. Owned by B UNDERHILL LLC. Public records show 20 open violations, 43 311 complaints on file. Risk signals: 1 bedbug report. Lucid Rents has 1 verified tenant review on this building.

HPD violations14last 7 years · class A, B, C

Evictions filed0last 7 years

Tenant reviews14.0 ★ avg

Rent-stab units—no coverage

Building age96 ybuilt 1930

311 complaints43last 7 years

01 / 10

Rental intelligence.

Neighborhood Median Rent

Brooklyn · March 2026

Studio

$2,900/mo

1 BR

$3,030/mo

2 BR

$3,350/mo

3 BR

$4,180/mo

4 BR

$4,500/mo

Compare this building's listings above against the neighborhood medians.

Seasonal Pattern

Best & worst months to sign a lease

Cheapest

March

Most expensive

May

JFMAMJJASOND

Potential savings: ~14% by timing your move to March.

Rent vs. area median Brooklyn

Studio

This building: $2,465 – $3,335

—Area: —

1 BR

This building: $2,576 – $3,484

73% aboveArea: $1,750

2 BR

This building: $2,848 – $3,852

—Area: —

3 BR

This building: $3,553 – $4,807

—Area: —

4 BR

This building: $3,825 – $5,175

—Area: —

Units Historic Rent 0 listings

—No dataNo recent listings

Neighborhood Rent Range Brooklyn

Studio

$2,900

$2,465 – $3,335

1 Bed

$1,750

$1,750

2 Bed

$3,350

$2,848 – $3,852

3 Bed

$4,180

$3,553 – $4,807

4 Bed

$4,500

$3,825 – $5,175

Range (P25 – P75)MedianBased on recent listings in Brooklyn

01 / 09

Rental intelligence.

02 / 10

Neighborhood risks.

within 0.75 mi

104 nearby

within 0.75 mi

Public-safety

shelters, methadone, halfway, sex offenders

24/7 Noise

sirens, construction, schools, rail, avenue traffic

Environmental

brownfields, industrial zones, sanitation

Block-level

3718

311 noise, rats, bedbug history

Sources: NYC DHS · DOB · 311 · DSNY · FDNY · NYS DCJS · NYS DECSee full report

02 / 10

Neighborhood risks.

02 / 10

Violations, 311, & more.

hpd · dob · 311 · acris
last 7 years

Violation & Complaint Trends

Monthly counts over the last 7 years · all data sources

Worsening

HPDTop Violations

14 total

Paint/Plaster
4
Pest Infestation
3
Water Leak
3
Roof/Ceiling
2
Door/Lock
1

311Top Complaints

43 total

Request Large Bulky Item Collection
13
Noise - Residential
8
UNSANITARY CONDITION
5
Noise - Street/Sidewalk
3
Rodent
3

DOBTop Filings

6 total

DOB Violations
6

EvictionsEvictions

0 filed

Evictions filed
0

Violations by Unit

(3 units)

UnitViolationsOpenLast Inspected

Recent records

Last 7 years

Class CVIOLATION DISMISSEDFeb 27, 2025
567 (C) § 27-2017, 27-2017.1, 27-2017.4, 27-2017.5, 27-2017.8, 27-2019, 27-2021 HMC: ABATE THE NUISANCE CONSISTING OF EVIDENCE OF RATS AND ALL UNDERLYING CAUSES CREATING THE PEST INFESTATIONS, BY USING INTEGRATED PEST MANAGEMENT (IPM), ELIMINATE ALL BURROW ENTRY AND PASSAGEWAYS, PEST NESTS, HOLES, GAPS OR CRACKS IN WALLS, CEILINGS, FLOORS, FIXING LEAKS AND MANAGING GARBAGE IN PUBLIC AREAS. EVIDENCE FOUND AT RODENTS DROPPINGS AT BUILDING FRONT YARD
Class AVIOLATION DISMISSEDJan 25, 2025
§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR AT CEILING IN THE KITCHEN LOCATED AT APT 4R, 4th STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM WEST AT NORTH
Class CNOT COMPLIED WITHJan 25, 2025
§ 27-2005, 27-2007, 27-2041.1 HMC, §238, § 309; § 107 (2) ( C) MDL AND 28 RCNY §25-171: REPLACE OR REPAIR THE SELF-CLOSING DOORS THAT IS MISSING OR DEFECTIVE HINGES AT EAST WALL LEADING TO CELLER AT PUBLIC HALL, 1st STORY
Class BVIOLATION DISMISSEDJan 25, 2025
§ 27-2026, 2027 HMC: PROPERLY REPAIR THE SOURCE AND ABATE THE EVIDENCE OF A WATER LEAK AT CEILING IN THE 3rd ROOM FROM EAST LOCATED AT APT 4R, 4th STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM WEST AT NORTH
Class BVIOLATION DISMISSEDJan 25, 2025
§ 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR AT CEILING IN THE 3rd ROOM FROM EAST LOCATED AT APT 4R, 4th STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM WEST AT NORTH

See all 14 HPD records

02 / 09

Violations, 311, & more.

03 / 10

What tenants actually say.

4.0 /5

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

1 reviews

5★

4★

100%

3★

2★

1★

Pros: Relatively clean and quiet despite being close to Atlantic Ave; Close to subways, restaurants, bars. Cons: Leaky roof on top floor, living room lighting was bad

positiveFeb 2024

Anonymous

View all 1 reviews

03 / 09

What tenants actually say.

04 / 10

Building amenities.

Building Amenities

1 amenity

OTHER

Good Cause

04 / 09

Building amenities.

05 / 10

The landlord.

B UNDERHILL LLC

Portfolio of 3 buildingsMEMBER: TOM ROSENBERGMail: 543 BEDFORD AVE, BROOKLYN, NY, 11211

Portfolio-level grade reflects the landlord's buildings across NYC, weighted by unit count. Individual building grades may differ.

View full landlord profile

buildings

4.0

avg score / 5

A-

portfolio grade

nearby owned

Ownership timeline · this building

ACRIS deeds and regulatory filings

1930Building constructed8 units · 4 floors
nowB UNDERHILL LLCOwner of record per HPD registration · manages 3 buildings · registration active through 2027-09-01.

05 / 09

The landlord.

06 / 10

Crime & safety.

11238 · last 12 months

Safety & Crime

Very safeSafety score · last 12 months

NYPD CompStat · updated weekly

LAST 12 MONTHS · 11238

Violent89

Property570

Quality-of-life771

Total incidents1,430

07 / 10

About this area.

Prospect Heights · 11238

12 UNDERHILL AVENUE · Brooklyn · 40.681° N, -73.965° W

Walk

Transit

Bike

Estimated from nearby transit & amenity data

4 bus stops nearby5 min

7 schools nearby3 min

Nearby Transit

BUS

WASHINGTON AV/PROSPECT PLB45
0.3 mi5 min
WASHINGTON AV/PROSPECT PLB45
0.3 mi6 min
BERGEN ST/CLASSON AVB65
0.3 mi7 min
VANDERBILT AV/PARK PLB69
0.4 mi8 min

Nearby Schools & Colleges

PUBLIC SCHOOLS

Public School 9 The Sarah Smith Garnet SchoolElementary
0.2 mi3 min
Public School 9 The Sarah Smith Garnet SchoolElementary
0.2 mi3 min
Gotham Professional Arts AcademyHigh School
0.2 mi4 min
P.s. K753 - School For Career DevelopmentHigh School
0.3 mi5 min

CHARTER SCHOOLS

Achievement First Endeavor Charter SchoolK-8
0.1 mi3 min
Brooklyn Prospect Charter School - Csd 13K-8
0.4 mi8 min
Brooklyn Prospect Charter School-Clinton Hill MiddleCharter
0.4 mi8 min

PRIVATE SCHOOLS

Luria Academy Of BrooklynElementary
0.2 mi4 min
League School - Vanderbilt
0.2 mi5 min
Starting Point - Bedford Stuyvesant
0.4 mi8 min

The neighborhood

Prospect Heights

Prospect Heights borders Prospect Park and the Brooklyn Museum. It's slightly more affordable than Park Slope, with a great mix of longtime residents and newcomers, excellent dining on Vanderbilt Ave.

6,631buildings tracked4.4avg LucidIQ$1,750median 1BR

58,047population$126kmedian income71%renters

CulturalWalkableDiverseUp-and-ComingParks

Explore Prospect Heights

Neighborhood overview

Prospect Heights→

Vibe · top buildings · landlords · schools · transit

Crime in 11238

See full breakdown→

Incident type · 6-month trend · vs. New York City average

Rent trends in Prospect Heights

Median rent & comparables→

1BR & 2BR averages · month-over-month · current listings

Nearby neighborhoods to explore

Bedford-Stuyvesant· 0.39 mi Carroll Gardens· 0.39 mi Fort Greene· 0.82 mi Park Slope· 0.93 mi Williamsburg· 1.28 mi

Browse all NYC neighborhoods

06 / 10

Crime & safety.

07 / 10

About this area.

08 / 10

History of the building.

construction · ownership · permits

At a glance

Year built1930

Floors4

Total units8

ClassC1

BBL3011220039

19301940195019601970198019902000201020202030

1930

Building constructed

8 units · 4 floors · class C1

now

Current owner: B UNDERHILL LLC

Portfolio includes 3 buildings.

Recent Activity

20 events

311MEDIUMFeb 6, 2026
Noise — Noise: Construction Before/After Hours (NM1)
311MEDIUMFeb 5, 2026
Noise — Noise: Jack Hammering (NC2)
311MEDIUMJun 27, 2025
Rodent — Rat Sighting
311MEDIUMMay 13, 2025
FLOORING/STAIRS — FLOOR
311MEDIUMMay 13, 2025
UNSANITARY CONDITION — PESTS
HPDHIGHFeb 27, 2025
HPD Class C Violation — 567 (C) § 27-2017, 27-2017.1, 27-2017.4, 27-2017.5, 27-2017.8, 27-2019, 27-2021 HMC: ABATE THE NUISANCE CONSISTING OF EV
HPDLOWJan 25, 2025
HPD Class A Violation — § 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR AT CEILING IN THE KITC
HPDHIGHJan 25, 2025
HPD Class C Violation — § 27-2005, 27-2007, 27-2041.1 HMC, §238, § 309; § 107 (2) ( C) MDL AND 28 RCNY §25-171: REPLACE OR REPAIR THE SELF-CLOSI
HPDMEDIUMJan 25, 2025
HPD Class B Violation — § 27-2026, 2027 HMC: PROPERLY REPAIR THE SOURCE AND ABATE THE EVIDENCE OF A WATER LEAK AT CEILING IN THE 3rd ROOM FROM E
HPDMEDIUMJan 25, 2025
HPD Class B Violation — § 27-2005 ADM CODE REPAIR THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE PLASTERED SURFACES AND PAINT IN A UNIFORM COLOR AT CEILING IN THE 3rd

07 / 09

History of the building.

10 / 10

Frequently asked questions.

What is the rent for a studio at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
Based on recent listing data, rent for a studio at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 ranges from $2,465 to $3,335 per month, with a median of $2,900.
What is the rent for a 1-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 1-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 ranges from $2,576 to $3,484 per month, with a median of $3,030.
What is the rent for a 2-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 2-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 ranges from $2,848 to $3,852 per month, with a median of $3,350.
What is the rent for a 3-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 3-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 ranges from $3,553 to $4,807 per month, with a median of $4,180.
What is the rent for a 4-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
Based on recent listing data, rent for a 4-bedroom at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 ranges from $3,825 to $5,175 per month, with a median of $4,500.
How does rent at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 compare to the neighborhood?
Compared to other buildings in the 11238 zip code: 1-bedroom rents are about 73% above the neighborhood median.
Is 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 rent stabilized?
Based on available records, 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 is not currently registered as rent stabilized. Rents at this building are likely set at market rate.
When is the cheapest time to rent at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
Based on historical listing data, March tends to be the most affordable month to sign a lease at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238, while May is typically the most expensive. Timing your move to March could save approximately 14% compared to peak pricing.
Who is the landlord of 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
The registered owner of 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 is B UNDERHILL LLC. You can view their full portfolio of buildings on Lucid Rents.
Is the landlord of 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 a good landlord?
12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238, owned by B UNDERHILL LLC, has an overall grade of A (4.0/5) on Lucid Rents. The building has 14 recorded violations. Tenants have left 1 review. Check tenant reviews for firsthand experiences.
What is the building rating for 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 has an overall grade of A with a score of 4.0 out of 5 on Lucid Rents. This score is based on violations, complaints, and tenant reviews.
Are there violations or complaints at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
Yes, 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 has 14 housing violations and 43 complaints on record. Visit the building page on Lucid Rents to see the full history, including violation classes and complaint types.
What amenities does 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 have?
12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 offers 1 amenities including Good Cause. View the full amenity list on the building page.
What schools are near 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
There are 10 schools near 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238, including 4 public schools, 3 charter schools, 3 private schools. Nearby schools include Public School 9 The Sarah Smith Garnet School (3 min walk), Public School 9 The Sarah Smith Garnet School (3 min walk), Gotham Professional Arts Academy (4 min walk), P.s. K753 - School For Career Development (5 min walk), Achievement First Endeavor Charter School (3 min walk), and more.
What public transit is near 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 has 4 transit options nearby. The closest include: bus: WASHINGTON AV/PROSPECT PL (B45), 0.27 mi away.
Is 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 safe? What is the crime rate nearby?
The 11238 zip code where 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 is located had 1,430 crime incidents in the past 2 years, including 89 violent crimes, 570 property crimes, and 771 quality-of-life incidents. Check the neighborhood report card for 11238 for full details.
When was 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 built and how many units does it have?
12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 was built in 1930, has 4 floors, contains 8 total units.
What do tenants say about living at 12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238?
12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 has 1 tenant review with an average rating of 4.0 out of 5. 0 out of 1 reviewers would recommend this building.

09 / 09

Frequently asked questions.

09 / 10

Similar buildings nearby.

347 LINCOLN PLACE

347 LINCOLN PLACE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238

BrooklynBuilt 1921

View building

105 LEFFERTS PLACE

105 LEFFERTS PLACE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238

BrooklynBuilt 1930

View building

340 ST JOHNS PLACE

340 ST JOHNS PLACE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238

BrooklynBuilt 1924

View building

575 GRAND AVENUE

575 GRAND AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238

BrooklynBuilt 2001

View building

08 / 09

Similar buildings nearby.

Embed this building’s record

Drop this scorecard into a tenant guide, blog post, or wiki. It updates itself as new violations are filed.

<iframe src="https://lucidrents.com/embed/building/a6ab6b33-3542-4f09-ac76-64fbdc55a5eb" width="100%" height="220" style="border:1px solid #e2e8f0;border-radius:12px" title="12 UNDERHILL AVENUE, Brooklyn, NY, 11238 — LucidRents building record" loading="lazy"></iframe>

Building record last updated August 19, 2026. Sourced from HPD, DOB, 311, and Lucid Rents data syncs.